Carbon neutral vs net zero: what the claims mean and how to spot greenwashing
A neutral guide to carbon neutral, net zero and climate positive claims, the standards behind them (ISO 14068, SBTi, UN HLEG) and India's 2024 greenwashing guidelines.
What does "carbon neutral" mean?
The IPCC (AR6 Working Group III glossary, 2022) describes carbon neutrality as the condition in which the human-caused carbon dioxide emissions linked to a subject are balanced by human-caused carbon dioxide removals. The subject can be a country, a company, a district, a product, a service or an event. The IPCC notes that it is often assessed over the full life cycle, including indirect (scope 3) emissions, and that some claims rely on offsets to balance what remains after the entity's own actions. It uses the separate term greenhouse gas neutrality when all gases, not only CO2, are balanced.
The main international standard for carbon neutrality claims is ISO 14068:2026, "Climate change management: Carbon neutrality", published by ISO in September 2026. It replaced ISO 14068-1:2023 (November 2023); ISO says only the number and title changed, not the content. According to ISO's description, it:
- covers organisations and products;
- requires the carbon footprint to be quantified, then reduced, and only then offset;
- follows a hierarchy that puts reductions and removals within the value chain ahead of offsetting;
- asks for a carbon neutrality management plan and for claims to be communicated transparently.
ISO 14068 (first published as ISO 14068-1) builds on the older British standard PAS 2060, and BSI, which published PAS 2060, now points users to the ISO standard.
The key point: a carbon neutral claim can be made while a company still emits a lot, as long as it measures its emissions, has a reduction plan and balances the rest with credits that meet the standard's rules. That is why the quality of those credits and the honesty of the plan matter so much.
Sources: IPCC AR6 Working Group III, Annex I: Glossary (2022); IPCC AR6 Working Group III, Summary for Policymakers (2022); UNFCCC, Paris Agreement (2015); ISO 14068-1:2023 Climate change management: Transition to net zero, Part 1: Carbon neutrality (catalogue page); BSI, PAS 2060 and ISO 14068-1 carbon neutrality; SBTi, The Corporate Net-Zero Standard (web page); SBTi, SBTi launches world-first net-zero corporate standard (28 October 2021); United Nations, High-Level Expert Group on the Net-Zero Emissions Commitments of Non-State Entities, Integrity Matters (2022); Press Information Bureau, CCPA issues Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing and Misleading Environmental Claims (15 October 2024, Release ID 2064963); Department of Consumer Affairs, Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Greenwashing or Misleading Environmental Claims, 2024 (PDF); ASCI, Draft Guidelines: Environmental/Green Claims (16 November 2023); European Commission, Directive (EU) 2024/825 on empowering consumers for the green transition (Transition Pathways page); Directive (EU) 2024/825, Official Journal of the European Union; MoEFCC, India First Biennial Transparency Report (BTR-1) to the UNFCCC; ISO 14068:2026 Climate change management: Carbon neutrality (ISO committee page; replaces ISO 14068-1:2023); SBTi blog: Countdown to validation: new resources to prepare for the Corporate Net-Zero Standard V2.0 (2026)
This article was prepared with AI assistance and checked by the GreenEye team against the sources shown in each section.
Want to understand this for your home or company?
Talk to us. We are happy to explain what this means for you in plain words. We do not sell carbon credits and we cannot promise any result, but we can help you think it through.
Talk to usShare this article
